Tesla’s Vision of the Future: Bold Innovation or Misguided Nostalgia?
During a recent event, Tesla revealed several prototypes, with one of the most talked-about being the Robovan. Elon Musk declared, “We want to change the look of the roads. The future should look like the future.”
It’s an interesting idea, but also problematic when you step back to examine it. The future, after all, is shaped not just by technology but also by society’s tastes and expectations.
If you ask anyone born in the ’80s — myself included — what the future would look like, I can confidently say: this ain’t it!
Predicting the Future or Jumping the Gun?
Musk’s statement implies that Tesla believes it can not only predict future trends but get there ahead of the curve. However, this assumption presents two significant risks:
- They could be wrong, designing vehicles that don’t align with the public’s vision of the future, resulting in wasted resources.
- They could be right, but too early. Even if they correctly anticipate future trends, public tastes today may not match Tesla’s futuristic designs.
The Cybertruck, with its unconventional appearance, provides a useful barometer for gauging public sentiment.
A Polarizing Design: Cybertruck’s Impact
To say that public perception of the Cybertruck has been mixed is an understatement. Social media is flooded with memes, roasts, and criticisms, while proud owners passionately defend it. But enthusiasm for the design hasn’t exactly taken off.
Rather than focusing on flaws specific to the Cybertruck, let’s explore the source of its inspiration.
The Media-Inspired Future
Musk has openly stated that “Blade Runner” and the amphibious car from “The Spy Who Loved Me” influenced the Cybertruck’s design. This reflects a vision of the future shaped by 1980s and 1990s pop culture rather than evolving societal preferences.
For me, the design initially resembled a poorly-textured Warthog from the Halo video games. While iconic in the gaming world, it’s hardly a practical road vehicle. And that seems to be part of the problem: form over function.
Design vs. Reality: The Growing List of Flaws
Reports of engineering defects with the Cybertruck are piling up, from broken fingers to vehicles rendered unusable by simple car washes. The stainless steel body, though visually striking, absorbs minimal impact, transmitting more force to occupants in crashes. One estimate claims it exerts four times more pressure on occupants compared to standard trucks.
Additionally, due to its dangerous design, the Cybertruck is banned in countries with strict pedestrian safety laws — leaving it exclusive to North America.
Robovan: Doubling Down on a Flawed Vision?
Despite the Cybertruck’s mixed reception, Musk appears determined to double down on his futuristic vision with the Robovan, which looks like it belongs more in a Judge Dredd movie than on a modern freeway.
Tesla’s human-assisted AI bots, with their eerie resemblance to the antagonists from “I, Robot”, raise further questions about these design choices. Why choose imagery that reminds people of dystopian antagonists? It’s baffling — though not entirely surprising, given the tech elite’s fascination with dystopian aesthetics.
The Pontiac Aztek Effect: Learning from the Past
Even if Tesla’s designs are ahead of their time, early adoption doesn’t guarantee success. Consider the Pontiac Aztek: a vehicle with a hatchback stance typical of modern SUVs. It was well-designed and affordable, yet consumers rejected it — largely because it was too different from what they expected from Pontiac.
The lesson? Even good designs fail if they arrive at the wrong time or clash with public expectations.
Nostalgic Visions of a Future That Never Was
Musk’s obsession with building the future based on past media reveals the biggest flaw in Tesla’s approach. His vision of the future feels outdated, like trying to design a car for the 1970s with a 1950s mindset.
We’ve all seen those old films predicting flying cars and moon colonies by the year 2000. Nostalgia is powerful, but it doesn’t align with modern realities. Trying to brute-force a vision into existence will likely lead to the same result the Metaverse faced: misguided ambition that fizzles out.
Can Vision Outlast the Present?
Even if Tesla’s futuristic designs are eventually embraced, they need to survive long enough for public tastes to catch up. History has shown that pushing change too aggressively often backfires. Cultural shifts take time to be accepted.
What Do You Think?
So, that’s my take. What’s yours?
Do you think Tesla’s attempts to “make the future now” will ultimately succeed, or are they too far ahead of the curve?
Let me know your thoughts in the comments below!
If your looking for a writer and like my style or just want to reach out, you can find me at Linkedin or email me!
